Grand Staircase-Escalante National Monument continues to demonstrate its scientific significance: Research published on tiny dinosaur eggs found in Kaiparowits Formation

Imagine, for a moment, scorching heat, sand, and wind whipping across the desert floor, chafing any exposed skin you neglected to cover while searching the rugged badlands of the Kaiparowits Plateau. Suddenly, you see something roughly the size of a marble, granted a marble that's been around for millions of years, but that's "eggs-actly" what happened when a group of paleontologists made a remarkable discovery in Grand Staircase-Escalante National Monument: marble-sized, bump-covered spheres that turned out to be tiny dinosaur eggs. 

For these paleontologists, it's like any other day at the office, and if you're a fan of the monument and its paleontology program, you've heard the hype. The Monument's Kaiparowits Plateau is home to world-class fossils. But dinosaur eggs? Yes, even dinosaur eggs; once again, the "living laboratory" lives up to its monumental reputation.

Side-by-side landscape views of the Kaiparowits Formation at Grand Staircase-Escalante National Monument. Photo credit: BLM Utah, Paria River District.
Side-by-side landscape views of the Kaiparowits Formation at Grand Staircase-Escalante National Monument. Photo credit: BLM Utah, Paria River District.

 

 

 

"The Kaiparowits Formation continues to provide significant discoveries," said Paria River District Paleontologist Dr. Alan Titus. "In terms of paleontological sites, the word 'significant' translates to significant enough that it is worthwhile to plan for and commit additional resources toward, in the interest of furthering scientific research because it will substantially increase our knowledge or contribute something new to science."

There you have it; even millions of years later, dinosaur eggs are still a thing, quietly waiting to be discovered. The question is how? How can something so small and fragile still be fossilized within the heart of this remote and rugged landscape?

"One might assume that the modern eggshells we're familiar with, such as chicken eggs, would be incredibly delicate objects and hard to fossilize, but it turns out dinosaur eggs tended to be pretty thick, and the Kaiparowits Formation's slightly alkaline chemistry is perfect for preserving them for millions of years," said Titus.

Left is a marble-sized fossilized dino egg and right is a dino eggschell fragment.
Left: Top view of a marble-size dinosaur bird egg discovered in the Kaiparowits Formation at Grand Staircase-Escalante National Monument in 2013 by paleontology field crews from the Denver Museum of Nature and Science. Right: Eggshell fragments of a Denver Museum of Nature and Science specimen. Photos courtesy of Sara Oser, a paleontologist at the University of Colorado Museum of Natural History.

 

 

 

Unquestionably, scientific exploration on the monument has come a long way since its establishment in 1996, and as paleontologists continue stepping back into time, it becomes apparent that there is still so much more to discover.

"The true diversity and significance of Kaiparowits dinosaur eggshells are just starting to be understood," said Sara Oser, a paleontologist at the University of Colorado Museum of Natural History.

Standard protocol for naming new eggs includes taking cross-sections of the shell and studying the tiny details under a microscope. However, upon closer examination, the cross-sections didn't reveal the standard soda straw-like air tubes Oser expected, as seen in other Cretaceous eggs. Instead, the tubes were more complex, weaving in and out of the polished cross-section. Unable to determine the complex 3-D paths of the tubes from the cross-section, Oser had the eggs scanned with Micro CT, a technique that maps 3-D structures of tiny objects in fine detail. 

Left: Rendered CT scan 3-D image of a single pore system looking down towards the inner surface of the eggshell. Right: Mesh node view revealing the complex branching networks of tubes inside the eggshell as seen with the use of a Macro Imaging System. Photos courtesy of Dr. Sara Oser, a paleontologist at the University of Colorado Museum of Natural History and meteorology and oceanography officer for the U.S. Navy.
Left: Rendered CT scan 3-D image of a single pore system looking down towards the inner surface of the eggshell. Right: Mesh node view revealing the complex branching networks of tubes inside the eggshell as seen with the use of a Macro Imaging System. Photos courtesy of Sara Oser, a paleontologist at the University of Colorado Museum of Natural History.

 

 

 

The results were astounding! The tubes formed complex branching networks, more bush-like than straw-like, and were infinitely more complicated than anything she had seen before. One of the best modern examples of eggs with such complex tube structures is those of ratites, large flightless birds like ostrich or emu. Although such birds probably hadn't evolved yet, Oser and team concluded the eggs likely belonged to some unknown, tiny species of bird-like dinosaur or a primitive bird.

However, the animal's exact nature is still a mystery because the eggs were not associated with bones. Still, given these eggs' uniqueness, the team could name them with a new scientific eggshell name (Stillatuberoolithus storrsi). Oser's article clarifies the etymology of the name, from the Latin stillare, to drip, in reference to the morphology of the nodes; from the Latin tuber, bump, in reference to the nodes; and ooliths, a combination of the Greek meaning 'egg stone' commonly applied to fossil eggshell. The oospecies name honors Dr. Glenn Storrs of the Cincinnati Museum of Natural History for his mentorship in the field. 

Left: Rendered CT scan of partial Kaiparowits egg (Denver Museum of Nature and Science specimen) cross section. Right: Radial thin section of Denver Museum of Nature and Science Kaiparowits eggshell specimen, measuring 0.5 mm. Photos courtesy of Dr. Sara Oser, a paleontologist at the University of Colorado Museum of Natural History and meteorology and oceanography officer for the U.S. Navy.
Left: Rendered CT scan of partial Kaiparowits egg (Denver Museum of Nature and Science specimen) cross section. Right: Radial thin section of Denver Museum of Nature and Science Kaiparowits eggshell specimen, measuring 0.5 mm. Photos courtesy of Sara Oser, a paleontologist at the University of Colorado Museum of Natural History.

 

 

 

Because the new eggs are among the smallest ever described from the Mesozoic fossil record, the team submitted their work to the prestigious scientific journal Nature and subsequently accepted it. You can read the entire paper in the link provided on the GSENM Paleontology Timeline or at Tiny, ornamented eggs and eggshell from the Upper Cretaceous of Utah represent a new ootaxon with theropod affinities | Scientific Reports (nature.com). Oser's photographs may be viewed at Dinosaur eggshell research on Grand Staircase-Escalante National Monument | Flickr.

Macro Imaging System used to help paleontologists better understand the physical structure of a dinosaur eggshell at the micro level.
Left: Macro Imaging System used to help paleontologists better understand the physical structure of a dinosaur eggshell at the micro level. Right: Paleontologists use macro imaging systems to help study the chemical and physical structure of a specimen, but before doing so, scientists must produce razor-thin sections of the paleontological specimen being analyzed. This requires specialized saw to help speed up the process, a technique used not just by paleontologists but also geologists, mineralogists, and other geoscientists. Photos courtesy of Sara Oser, a paleontologist at the University of Colorado Museum of Natural History.

 

 

 

Getting a paper into Nature is challenging, so the team had reason to celebrate. Titus was emphatic about how important the find was.  

"The serendipitous discovery and subsequent naming of these new eggs underscore just how little we know and how important Grand Staircase's largely unexplored fossil resources are for understanding the complex ecology of the dinosaurs just before their catastrophic extinction," said Titus. "Plenty more discoveries like this are waiting to be made in the Kaiparowits region, and I am thankful that researchers and public institutions are available to preserve these important fossils for future generations, sometimes collecting specimens even when their true importance is yet to be understood."

September 2023 marks the 27th anniversary of the Monument's designation timeline graphic
As September 2023 marks the 27th anniversary of the Monument's designation, this "living laboratory" continues to produce globally significant, world-class specimens. If you're a fan of the Monument and its paleontology program, then chances are you have heard the hype _ the Monument has achieved several significant milestones in the last few years. This timeline outlines these banner accomplishments. Illustration credit: BLM Utah, Paria River District.

 

 

 

Story by:

David Hercher, Public Affairs Specialist